California Gov. Gavin Newsom has signed legislation formally recognizing two of Islam’s most important religious observances as state holidays, adding another chapter to the ongoing debate over religion, government and public schools in the nation’s largest state.
Assembly Bill 2017 adds Eid al-Fitr and Eid al-Adha to California’s list of state-recognized holidays. The legislation makes California the second state, following Washington, to recognize both Islamic holidays statewide.
The practical effects, however, are more limited than the phrase “state holiday” might initially suggest.
The law permits public schools and community colleges to close for the two holidays, but does not require them to do so. Private businesses likewise are not ordered to shut down, and California courts are required to remain open. State employees can become eligible to observe the holidays under applicable state employment rules.
Eid al-Fitr marks the conclusion of Ramadan, the Islamic holy month during which observant Muslims fast from dawn until sunset. Eid al-Adha commemorates Abraham’s willingness to sacrifice his son in obedience to God, a story also familiar within Judaism and Christianity, although the traditions differ on important details.
The legislation had already attracted attention while moving through Sacramento. AB 2017 passed the California Assembly 64-1 before proceeding through the Senate. The measure also authorized public schools to acknowledge the two holidays in educational settings and gave local districts discretion concerning closures.
California’s move does not stand alone.
Newsom has also signed AB 395, broader legislation dealing with religious holidays, as well as AB 1763, which concerns excused student absences for religious observances. The governor’s official September 30 legislative update confirms both measures were signed.
That wider context matters because California lawmakers have simultaneously considered protections involving Jewish observances including Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur. In other words, Sacramento is expanding official accommodation of several religious traditions rather than simply creating mandatory statewide shutdowns for Islamic holidays.
Still, AB 2017 will inevitably generate debate.
Supporters argue that California has a large and diverse Muslim population and that officially recognizing Eid gives Muslim students and government employees treatment comparable to people whose major religious observances are already accommodated.
Critics have raised questions about how far government institutions should go in formally recognizing religious celebrations, particularly inside public schools. Earlier coverage of the bill noted concerns about school neutrality because the legislation allows schools to “acknowledge and celebrate” the holidays through curriculum.
Washington traveled this road first. Its legislature added Eid al-Fitr and Eid al-Adha to its list of unpaid state holidays in 2025, making it the first state to provide statewide recognition.
California has now followed.
What Newsom signed does not force every Californian to observe Eid, does not require businesses to close, and does not turn the two days into mandatory school closures. But it does give the Islamic holidays formal recognition under California law.
And in a state where practically every cultural question eventually becomes a political argument, don’t expect the debate over where religious accommodation ends and government endorsement begins to disappear anytime soon.
Leave a Comment